The church registers escaped the fire and are complete from 1653. The list of incumbents goes back, with some gaps, to 1297:
| 1297 | William | 1638 | Joannes Percival |
| 1305 | Gulielmus de Compton | 1643 | John Barnard |
| 1320 | Johannes Lodecote | 1647 | John Grizlie |
| 1350 | Robertus de Eversden | 1650 | Daniel Rolls |
| 1351 | Johannes de Middleton | 1657 | Joshua Tomkins |
| 1356 | William Whytheres | 1675 | Joannes Ellis |
| 1362 | Joannes Symond | 1694 | Daniel Dickenson |
| 1376 | Nicholas Ellyot | 1701 | Joseph Creffield |
| 1382 | Thomas Milton | 1728 | John Woodford |
| 1386 | Willielmus Urry | 1760 | William Gother |
| 1394 | Johannes Bennet | 1766 | Robert Gibbs |
| 1418 | Joannes Ledys | 1797 | Thomas Bowerman |
| 1425 | Robertus Knight | 1833 | Collingwood F. Fenwick |
| 1449 | Richard Canon | 1856 | John Pellow Gaze |
| 1450 | Willielmus Newport | 1892 | Robert Leslie Morris |
| Intermission of 66 years | 1909 | Courtney Arthur Shaw | |
| 1525 | Willielmus Botyll | 1930 | Arthur A. P. Winser |
| 1529 | Joannes Bust | 1942 | Thomas Kirkbride |
| 1538 | Robertus Dixon | 1949 | Frederick Appleton (priest in charge) |
| 1539 | Richardus Ellyot | 1953 | Robert Joselyn Bowyer |
| Intermission of 21 years | Gordon Broome | ||
| 1586 | Robert Birch (curate in charge) | 1980 | Stephen Palmer |
| 1586 | William Hayes (curate in charge) | 1992 | Tim Eady |
| Hayes was ejected the same year and the parish annexed to Freshwater. |
2008 | Malcolm Williams | |